South Vietnam President Ngo Dinh Diem was a paranoid man with an enormous ego. In accepting U.S. military and financial aid, Diem agreed to allow the American military to train and direct the South Vietnamese military efforts against the Communists. However, Diem feared sharing success with his own officers, even when the American military recommended promotions. Rather than promote and share the limelight of military success with his generals and his army, Diem would often ridicule them because he feared they would receive too much attention and power. In one case, Diem summoned a colonel who had been recommended for a promotion and told him that his promotion would be denied if he incurred any more casualties. The effect of this was that the South Vietnamese military was being told to do one thing by the U.S. military advisors, while fearing Diem at the same time. Diem was corrupt, oppressive, and difficult to work with. Unfortunately, his attitude clearly affected the way his men fought in battle. U.S. advisors found it difficult to work with ARVN troops at times and reports of their abilities are mixed, depending on which veteran one interviews, or who is doing the writing. Suffice it to say that it would be unfair to make a group judgment about their effort and ability. Some were more effective and courageous than others. To overstate the obvious, though, the South Vietnamese troops were no match for their North Vietnamese counterparts without significant U.S. aid and advise.
Following is a review a few key battles. This is not presented as a comprehensive list, rather just some of the highlights with brief comments.
Jan. 2, 1963 - Ap Bac, near the Cambodian border:
ARVN forces with 51 U.S. advisors attempted
to capture a Communist radio center.
Expecting an easy victory, ARVN forces
were surprised to find about 400 Vietcong
troops at Ap Bac. Still, the
ARVN had superior numbers and the support of U.S.
helicopters. ARVN military leaders,
fearing reprisals from Diem, refused to listen to
U.S. advisors and delayed actions.
ARVN forces were not aggressive and were
defeated. Three U.S. advisors
were killed, six were wounded, and five helicopters
were destroyed. Results of this
battle convinced the U.S. military that they needed to
take full control of the war.
This also opened a widening rift between Vietnamese
military leaders, the U.S., and President
Diem. Ten months later, Diem was
overthrown and murdered in a military
coup.
Aug. 2, 1964 - North Vietnamese patrol boats
fire on USNS Maddox in Gulf of Tonkin
The USNS Maddox was patrolling in the
Gulf of Tonkin outside North Vietnam’s
when three North Vietnamese torpedo
boats approached at high speed.
Warning shots did not stop the attack,
so the Maddox destroyed one of the boats and
damaged a second. Two fired torpedoes
missed the Maddox by 200 yards.
Aug. 4, 1964 - Apparent attack of five torpedo
boats against USNS Maddox and
USNS C. Turner Joy in Gulf of Tonkin:
On a stormy evening in the Gulf of
Tonkin an inexperienced Maddox radar man
reported what he judged to be five
torpedo boats 36 nautical miles away and
heading toward the ships. The
ships called for air support and opened fire. Initial
reports from the ships indicated two
boats were sunk and two were damaged.
However, U.S. intelligence later revealed
that the apparent enemy ships shown on
the radar were actually radar blips.
Pilots, including the highly respected and
decorated James Stockdale, reported
they saw nothing in the waters of the Gulf of
Tonkin that night.
Further, the North Vietnamese contend
to this day that they did not have boats in the
Gulf of Tonkin that night. However,
President Johnson was convinced by field
commanders that an attack had taken
place. Johnson ordered an air attack against
North Vietnamese bases, which resulted
in the destruction of 25 torpedo boats and
an oil storage depot. Infuriated
and wanting to show public support for President
Johnson even though it was an election
year, Congress quickly approved the Gulf of
Tonkin Resolution on August 11, 1964.
This resolution gave the president the
authority to take any action, including
military force, he deemed necessary to repel
any armed attack against the United
States or to assist any member of the Southeast
Asia Treaty Organization, including
South Vietnam. This critical resolution, based on
conflicting reports and unclear information,
essentially gave the president the right to
make war without a declaration of war.
Only Congress can declare war and neither
Congress nor the President wanted to
pursue that because it might have caused
both China and the Soviet Union to
declare war against the United States.
Intelligence reports and historical
reviews of the Gulf of Tonkin incident indicate that
there was likely no attack against
the Maddox and C. Turner Joy on the evening of
August 4, 1964. Irrespective,
the result remains the same, the United States was
about to go to war without declaring
it. Consider this quote by President Johnson
prior to his decision to send in ground
forces in 1965: “For all I know, our Navy was
shooting at whales out there.”
Jan/Feb, 1965 - Vietcong attack several US
bases:
The North Vietnamese Army and the Viet
Cong persistently attacked U.S. bases and
sites where U.S. advisors were known
to gather. These types of attacks included
planting bombs in cars, on streets,
or in buildings, hit and run guerrilla tactics,
sending in a barrage of mortars, and
all out attacks.
Mar. 2, 1965 -- Rolling Thunder -- sustained
bombing of North Vietnam:
Concerned about the way the war was
progressing, President Johnson approved
Operation Rolling Thunder. This
sustained bombing of North Vietnam military
positions and the Ho Chi Minh Trail
involved over 200,000 in three years. Judged by
many to be relatively ineffective in
stopping the flow of men and materiel into the
south. Still, this operation
showed the U.S. would not sit idly by and watch casualties
grow without a response. During
Operation Rolling Thunder, the United States
dropped more bombs on North Vietnam
than it had on Europe in all of World War II.
Mar. 8, 1965 - first combat troops land at
Danang
Though not a battle per se, this key
event was a major move on the part of the United
States. Led to many battles involving
significantly more U.S. troops and casualties.
Dec., 1967 -- Communist attack on Khe Sanh
- major US base:
Approximately 20,000 North Vietnamese
were spotted gathering outside of Khe
Sahn, site of a major U.S. base.
Skirmishes were fought as U.S. forces and materiel
were flown in. On January 21,
1968 the NVA pounded Khe Sanh with mortars and
artillery. The fighting at Khe
Sanh was perhaps the most intense of the entire war,
involving hand-to-hand combat at times.
U.S. marines held off the siege after 77
days of fighting. American casualties
totaled 205 killed, 443 wounded, 2 missing.
North Vietnamese casualties totaled
807 killed. Over 23,000 artillery rounds were
fired, 1,170 sorties were flown dropping
over 3 million pounds of explosives, 611,000
pounds of napalm, and 5,000 bombs.
Incredibly, not long after the costly U.S. victory,
the Khe Sanh base was abandoned.
General Westmoreland had described the
Khe Sanh base as critical to the U.S.
effort and he believed that the siege of Khe
Sanh was the major effort by the NVA.
In fact, the Khe Sanh siege appears to have
been part of a larger plan by the Communists
to mount an all out offensive, Tet.
Jan. 31, 1968: Tet Offensive
Tet is the most important holiday in
Vietnam and there was an unofficial cease fire in
place. At 2:45 a.m. on January
31, 1968 the American Embassy in Saigon was
attacked. This was the start
of perhaps the best known battle of the Vietnam War.
More than 70,000 North Vietnamese and
Viet Cong troops attacked over a hundred
cities, villages, and military sites
throughout South Vietnam. Among the many battles
fought during the Tet Offensive, one
of the more brutal battles occurred in the city of
Hue. In Hue, civilians were tortured
and executed by the thousands before the city
was finally liberated. Within
weeks the Communists were badly beaten. About
45,000 NVA and VC troops were killed
and nearly 7,000 prisoners were taken. The
U.S. forces suffered 1,536 deaths,
7,764 wounded, and 11 missing in action. South
Vietnamese forces had 2,788 killed
and 8,299 wounded. Innocent civilians were
tortured and killed: 14,000 killed,
24,000 wounded, over 600,000 were left homeless.
Another casualty of this battle was
American public opinion, which turned
dramatically against the war.
May, 1969 - Hill 937 - Battle of Ap Bia Mountain
- aka Hamburger Hill (near Laos):
The war changed after Tet and Richard
Nixon was elected President. After losing the
Tet Offensive so decisively, the Communists
were wary of U.S. firepower, and they
also knew the Americans would eventually
leave as the gradual withdrawal of U.S.
troops had been announced. In
1969, the Communists normally avoided large
battles. They chose instead to
hit, then run and hide in Cambodia and Laos. To try
to halt the Communist attacks, the
U.S. would send units out to search and destroy
the enemy. During one of their
missions, the 101st Airborne Division attacked
Communist forces on a steep hill in
the A Shau Valley. The battle for this hill, known
as Hill 937, was incredibly fierce
as the NVA and VC decided to stand and fight due
to their favorable position on the
hill. American forces relentlessly attacked the
enemy for six days, at times crawling
on their stomachs up the hill. Eventually, U.S.
forces took the hill, but casualties
were high, causing even more political and public
dissent about the war. American
losses were 46 killed and 400 wounded and
NVA/VC losses were 633 killed.
Within days of winning the battle for Hill 937, the
Americans once again abandoned the
area, which further inflamed public outrage.
Military leaders responded that they
were not fighting for geography, rather, they just
wanted to find and kill the enemy.
April 30, 1970 - US & ARVN invade Cambodia
This is discussed in greater length
in another lesson. U.S. and ARVN forces
attacked NVA/VC sanctuaries in Cambodia.
Succeded in capturing a great deal of
enemy materiel, but set off a firestorm
of protest in the United States.
Mar. 31, 1972 - NV Easter Offensive across
17th Parallel
In 1972, peace negotiations were progressing
in Paris and American troop
withdrawals continued. The North
Vietnamese took the opportunity to launch their
biggest offensive since Tet.
They stormed across the DMZ and easily pushed South
Vietnamese forces and civilians further
south. Thousands of civilians fled in a
chaotic refugee escape and many South
Vietnamese troops abandoned their
positions. Eventually, the attack
was repelled with U.S. support, but it showed
glaring weaknesses in the abilities
of the ARVN without the United States being
actively involved. The attack
also further hampered peace talks.